State your opinion with reasons as an auditor, whether the following are capital or deferred revenue or revenue expenditure [5×2] i. A company compensated Rs. 10,000 to a worker who suffered in…

Detailed Analysis of Each Item

i. Rs. 10,000 Compensation to Worker

Classification: Revenue Expenditure Reasoning:

• The compensation is paid due to an accident, which is an operating loss (not an investment in an asset).
• It does not generate any future economic benefit—it is an immediate expense to be recognized in the income statement (P&L).
• Auditors must ensure that such payments are not capitalized (e.g., as part of employee benefits) unless they relate to a long-term asset acquisition (which is not the case here).
• IAS 37 (Provisions, Contingent Liabilities, and Contingent Assets) requires recognition of compensated absences only if they meet specific criteria, but a one-time accident compensation is purely an expense.

Journal Entry:

Loss on Accident A/c (P&L)       Dr. 10,000
Cash/Bank A/c                   Cr. 10,000

---

ii. Rs. 30,000 Theft from Shop

Classification: Revenue Expenditure Reasoning:

• Theft is an unforeseen loss and does not contribute to future economic benefits.
• It is an operating expense (similar to bad debts, shrinkage, or vandalism) and must be charged to the income statement in the period incurred.
• Auditors should verify that the loss is not understated (e.g., by checking inventory records, security logs, and insurance claims).
• IAS 10 (Events After Reporting Period) may require disclosure if the theft occurred after the reporting date but before financial statements are authorized.

Journal Entry:

Loss by Theft A/c (P&L)          Dr. 30,000
Cash/Bank A/c                   Cr. 30,000

---

iii. Rs. 20,000 Allowance to Employee for Raw Material

Classification: Capital Expenditure (Deferred Revenue Expenditure) Reasoning:

• The allowance is not a salary or recurring expense but a reimbursement for a specific business purpose (purchasing raw materials).
• Since it directly increases inventory (a current asset), it should be capitalized rather than expensed immediately.
• IAS 16 (Property, Plant, and Equipment) and IAS 2 (Inventories) require that costs incurred to acquire inventories be included in their carrying amount.
• Auditors must ensure that the allowance is not misclassified as a salary expense, which would distort gross profit margins.

Journal Entry:

Raw Material A/c (Balance Sheet) Dr. 20,000
Cash/Bank A/c                   Cr. 20,000

---

iv. Rs. 150,000 Purchase of 2 Laptops

Classification: Capital Expenditure Reasoning:

• Laptops are long-term assets (useful life >1 year) used for business operations (e.g., accounting, management, sales).
• Their cost must be capitalized in the balance sheet under Computer Equipment and depreciated over their useful life (typically 3-5 years).
• IAS 16 requires that all costs to acquire and prepare an asset for use (including taxes, transport, and setup) be capitalized.
• Auditors should check for proper authorization, asset registers, and depreciation policies to ensure compliance.

Journal Entry:

Computer Equipment A/c (Balance Sheet) Dr. 150,000
Cash/Bank A/c                   Cr. 150,000

---

v. Rs. 2 Million Machine Purchase (Installments + Interest)

Classification: Capital Expenditure Reasoning:

• The machine is a fixed asset with a useful life >1 year, so its full cost must be capitalized.
• Deferred payment terms (Rs. 1M now, Rs. 1M later + 20% interest) mean the total cost is Rs. 2.2M (Rs. 1M + Rs. 1.2M).
• Interest on deferred payment is capitalized (per IAS 23 – Borrowing Costs) because it is directly attributable to asset acquisition.
• Auditors must ensure:
  1. No premature capitalization of interest (only actual borrowing costs related to the asset qualify).
  2. Proper disclosure of finance lease obligations (if applicable).
  3. Depreciation is calculated on the total cost (Rs. 2.2M) over the asset’s life.

Calculation of Total Cost:

• First installment: Rs. 1,000,000 (paid immediately)
• Second installment: Rs. 1,000,000 + 20% interest = Rs. 1,200,000 (due in 6 months)
• Total cost: Rs. 2,200,000

Journal Entries:

Machine A/c (Balance Sheet)       Dr. 2,200,000
Bank A/c                         Cr. 1,000,000
Deferred Payment Liability A/c   Cr. 1,200,000

Depreciation Entry (Assuming 10% Straight-Line Method):

Depreciation Expense A/c (P&L)   Dr. 220,000 (10% of 2.2M)
Accumulated Depreciation A/c     Cr. 220,000

---

Key Auditor Considerations

1. Substance Over Form: Ensure transactions are recorded based on economic reality, not just legal form (e.g., a lease may be a finance lease in substance).
2. Matching Principle: Revenue expenditures must be matched against revenue in the same period, while capital expenditures provide future benefits.
3. Going Concern Assumption: If the business is not a going concern, some capital expenditures may need to be expensed immediately (e.g., under IAS 10).
4. Fraud Risk: Theft and compensation claims may indicate internal control weaknesses (e.g., poor security, lack of accident reporting).
5. Tax Implications: Capital expenditures may qualify for depreciation allowances, while revenue expenditures are fully deductible in the same year.

---

Common Pitfalls for Students

• Misclassifying allowances as revenue expenses (e.g., treating the Rs. 20,000 raw material allowance as a salary).
• Ignoring interest on deferred payments (must be capitalized if directly attributable).
• Not verifying useful life assumptions (e.g., laptops may have a 3-year life, not 10 years).
• Failing to distinguish between capital and deferred revenue (e.g., rent paid in advance is a current asset, not capital expenditure).