EnglishNEB 2078 (old course)
Answer any five of the following questions. a. Explain the significance of the repetition of the words ..."low, dull, quick sound much such a sound as a watch makes when enveloped in cotton". Does…
15Answer any five of the following questions. a. Explain the significance of the repetition of the words ..."low, dull, quick sound-much such a sound as a watch makes when enveloped in cotton". Does this sound encourage the narrator to commit crime? (The Tell-Tale Heart) b. Why does Hansel drop shiny pebbles on the way to the forest? (Hansel and Gretel) c. Why are the children like Tammy waiting for adoption? (The Children Who Wait) d. How does the narrator plan to reconcile his life of toil with civilized living? (About Love) e. Does death have any meaning in the poem? Explain. (Full Fathom Five...) f. What message does the boy's aunt leave in the kitchen before she goes to her mother's home? (A story)
Answer
a. Significance of the Repetition of the Words "...low, dull, quick sound—much such a sound as a watch makes when enveloped in cotton" in The Tell-Tale Heart
Edgar Allan Poe’s "The Tell-Tale Heart" is a psychological horror story that explores the narrator’s descent into madness due to an obsession with an old man’s "vulture-like" eye. The repetition of the phrase "...low, dull, quick sound—much such a sound as a watch makes when enveloped in cotton" is a crucial literary device that heightens tension, reveals the narrator’s paranoia, and ultimately leads to his confession of guilt.
1. Symbolism of the Sound
The sound is described as:
- Low and dull → Represents the oppressive, suffocating guilt the narrator feels.
- Quick → Mirrors the rapid, erratic heartbeat of a guilty conscience.
- Like a watch enveloped in cotton → Suggests a distorted, muffled perception of time, as if the narrator is trapped in a nightmare where time stretches and contracts unpredictably.
This sound is not just auditory but psychological—it symbolizes the uncontrollable nature of guilt, which grows louder and more insistent until it consumes the narrator’s mind.
2. The Sound as a Manifestation of the Narrator’s Madness
The narrator claims to be sane, yet his obsession with the old man’s eye and his hyper-sensitivity to sound prove otherwise. The repetition of this sound:
- Amplifies his paranoia – He becomes convinced that the neighbors (or even the police) can hear it, though in reality, it is only in his mind.
- Represents his fractured psyche – The sound is not real but a hallucination, a product of his guilt manifesting as an auditory torment.
- Forces his confession – The sound becomes so overwhelming that he breaks down, admitting, "It is the beating of his hideous heart!"
3. Does the Sound Encourage the Narrator to Commit Crime?
No, the sound does not cause the crime, but it reveals the narrator’s pre-existing instability. The murder was already planned due to his obsession with the eye, but the sound is the consequence of his guilt, not the reason for the act.
However, the sound intensifies his psychological torment, making him unable to escape his own mind. By the end, the sound destroys him, proving that no crime goes unpunished—even by one’s own conscience.
b. Why Does Hansel Drop Shiny Pebbles on the Way to the Forest? (Hansel and Gretel)
In the Brothers Grimm fairy tale "Hansel and Gretel", Hansel drops shiny pebbles on the path to the forest to:
- Mark the Way Home – The pebbles act as a trail of breadcrumbs, helping the children retrace their steps when they get lost.
- Demonstrate Forethought – Unlike Gretel, who is passive, Hansel plans ahead, showing his resourcefulness in survival.
- Symbolize Hope and Intelligence – While the stepmother and father abandon the children, Hansel’s use of pebbles shows that he is not helpless—he can outsmart danger.
However, the pebbles fail because:
- The dew melts them (or birds eat them), leaving no trace.
- The stepmother’s cruelty ensures the children are truly lost, leading to their encounter with the witch’s gingerbread house.
This moment foreshadows their ordeal—Hansel’s cleverness is tested, and the story shifts from childlike trust to survival against evil.
c. Why Are the Children Like Tammy Waiting for Adoption? (The Children Who Wait)
In "The Children Who Wait" (by Pearl S. Buck), children like Tammy are waiting for adoption because:
- Abandonment Due to Poverty or War – Many children in China (where the story is set) are orphaned due to:
- Famine (e.g., the Great Chinese Famine of 1959–61).
- War (e.g., conflicts leaving families destitute).
- Parental inability to care for them (economic struggles).
- Cultural and Social Stigma – In some societies, unwanted children (especially girls) are abandoned due to:
- Gender discrimination (preference for sons).
- Lack of social support for single mothers.
- Government and Orphanage Systems – Many children end up in state-run orphanages where they wait for:
- Domestic or international adoption (if they meet criteria).
- Foster care, but often with limited resources.
- Medical or Physical Disabilities – Some children (like Tammy, who may have a clubfoot) are less likely to be adopted, making their wait longer.
The story highlights the tragedy of systemic neglect and the hope for a better future through adoption.
d. How Does the Narrator Plan to Reconcile His Life of Toil with Civilized Living? (About Love)
In "About Love" (by Fyodor Dostoevsky), the narrator (a poor, uneducated worker) struggles to balance his harsh, laborious life with the desire for "civilized" love and companionship. His plan involves:
1. Self-Education and Cultural Aspiration
- He reads books (e.g., "The Lives of the Saints") to improve his mind and understand love beyond mere physical attraction.
- He observes the behavior of "civilized" people (e.g., the landlady’s daughter) to learn etiquette and refinement.
2. Economic Stability Through Hard Work
- He works tirelessly (e.g., as a copyist, laborer) to save money and rise socially.
- He dreams of buying land and marrying a woman of higher status, believing that wealth will grant him respect.
3. The Illusion of Love vs. Reality
- He romanticizes love, thinking it will elevate his status.
- However, his naivety and lack of real social connections make his plans unrealistic.
- The story suggests that true love cannot be achieved through mere ambition—it requires mutual understanding and equality, which he lacks.
4. The Tragic Outcome
- His obsession with the landlady’s daughter leads to disappointment when she rejects him.
- His desire for civilization clashes with his reality, showing that social mobility is not enough for genuine love.
*e. Does Death Have Any Meaning in the Poem? Explain. (Full Fathom Five...)*
Shakespeare’s "Full Fathom Five" (from The Tempest) describes the transformation of the drowned spirit Ariel into a celestial being. The poem explores death as a transition, not an end, giving it profound meaning:
1. Death as a Natural Process
- The speaker declares:
"Full fathom five thy father lies; Of his bones are coral made..." This suggests that death is part of nature’s cycle—the drowned man’s body dissolves and transforms into beautiful coral and pearls.
2. Immortality Through Art and Memory
- The poem elevates the dead man’s legacy:
- His bones become coral (symbolizing eternity).
- His soul is freed to "dance like a daffodil" in the heavens.
- This implies that death is not an extinction but a rebirth into something greater.
3. Spiritual and Mythological Meaning
- The imagery of Ariel (the airy spirit) rising from the sea suggests a mythological or spiritual afterlife.
- The daffodils and coral symbolize beauty and renewal, making death part of a divine order.
4. Contrast with Mortal Fear
- Unlike human fears of decay and oblivion, the poem presents death as harmonious and purposeful.
- The ocean’s embrace is gentle and transformative, not terrifying.
Conclusion: Death in the poem has deep meaning—it is not an end but a metamorphosis, where the dead become part of nature’s eternal cycle and ascend to a higher, spiritual existence.
f. What Message Does the Boy’s Aunt Leave in the Kitchen Before She Goes to Her Mother’s Home? (A Story)
In "A Story" (by James Joyce, from Dubliners), the boy’s aunt leaves a note in the kitchen before visiting her mother. The message is simple but symbolic:
1. The Exact Message (Assuming the Story Refers to "The Boarding House" or Similar Joycean Themes)
While Joyce’s "A Story" is not explicitly named, if we consider the **aunt’s role in facilitating the boy’s (or a young man’s) romantic or social advancement, the note likely contains:
- A request to keep the house tidy (e.g., "Leave the kitchen clean").
- A hint of secrecy or expectation (e.g., "Wait for me—something important will happen").
- **A subtle encouragement for the boy to pursue his interests (e.g., "Don’t worry, I’ll be back soon").
*2. Deeper Symbolism (If Referring to "The Boarding House")*
In "The Boarding House" (another Joyce story), the aunt arranges a marriage for her niece, Polly. If this is the context:
- The note might signal a hidden agenda—perhaps preparing the boy for a romantic encounter.
- It could foreshadow betrayal or manipulation, as the aunt controls the boy’s fate without his full awareness.
3. Possible Literal Interpretation (If from a Different Source)
If the question refers to a different short story (e.g., a Nepali or regional tale), the aunt’s message might be:
- "Do not eat the food I left—it’s for your mother." (A common cultural instruction.)
- "Lock the door when I leave." (A precautionary note.)
Most Likely Answer (Based on Joyce’s Style): The aunt’s note is deceptively innocent but hints at a larger scheme, reflecting Joyce’s theme of hidden motives in domestic life. The boy may misinterpret her kindness as genuine, unaware of the social or romantic traps she sets.
(Word count: ~1,100)
Discussion
Loading…