FIN211 Basic Finance

Basic FinanceUnit 58 min read

Stock Valuation & Dividend Discount Models (DDM)

Unit 5 of Basic Finance explores how to value common stocks using dividend discount models (DDM), including constant growth, zero-growth, and non-constant growth scenarios, while linking theory to real-world Nepali and global applications like NEPSE stocks, eSewa dividends, and Pathao’s equity financing.

TAKEAWAYS:

  • Dividend Discount Model (DDM) values stocks by discounting future dividends to present value, assuming dividends reflect intrinsic worth.
  • Three DDM variants: Zero-growth (perpetual dividends), constant-growth (Gordon Growth Model), and multi-stage growth (changing growth rates).
  • Key inputs: Required return (discount rate), dividend growth rate, and terminal value (for multi-stage models).
  • Real-world ties: NEPSE-listed companies (e.g., NMB Bank) use DDM for share pricing; eSewa’s dividend policy reflects investor expectations.
  • Limitations: Assumes dividends are the sole value driver and ignores non-dividend cash flows (e.g., buybacks).
  • Exam focus: Numerical problems (e.g., calculating stock price given dividends/growth) and conceptual questions (e.g., why DDM fails for non-dividend stocks).

1. What is Stock Valuation?

Stock valuation estimates the intrinsic value of a company’s equity by analyzing its future cash flows (primarily dividends) and discounting them to present value. Unlike market price (which fluctuates daily), intrinsic value is a theoretical "fair price" based on fundamentals.

Why does this matter?

  • Investors (e.g., NEPSE traders) use it to decide whether a stock is overvalued or undervalued.
  • Companies (e.g., NMB Bank) use it to justify share buybacks or dividend policies.
  • Regulators (e.g., SEBON) scrutinize valuations for IPOs or mergers.

2. The Dividend Discount Model (DDM): Core Idea

DDM states:

Stock Price = Present Value of All Future Dividends

DDM Intuition: Cash Flow vs. ValueDr.Cr.To Future Dividends (D₁, D₂, ...)0To Terminal Value (P_T)0By Discount Rate (r)0By Present Value (P₀)0
DDM treats a stock as the present value of all future cash flows (dividends) discounted back to today.

Mathematically: where:

  • = Current stock price
  • = Dividend at time
  • = Required return (discount rate, often = cost of equity)

Assumption: Dividends are the only source of return (ignores capital gains from price appreciation).


3. Three Types of DDMs

DDMs vary based on dividend growth patterns. Below is a comparison table of the three models:

Model Dividend Growth Formula When to Use Example
Zero-Growth DDM Dividends never grow () Mature firms (e.g., utility stocks) NTC’s perpetual dividend policy
Constant-Growth DDM Dividends grow at fixed Stable firms (e.g., NMB Bank) Sagarmatha Company (10% growth)
Multi-Stage DDM Growth changes over time High-growth firms (e.g., Daraz pre-IPO) Pathao’s early-stage vs. mature phase

4. Worked Example: Constant-Growth DDM (Gordon Growth Model)

Scenario: Sagarmatha Company paid a dividend of Rs 8 last year (). Analysts expect dividends to grow at 10% annually forever. If the required return () is 15%, what is the fair stock price?

Time (Years)Value (₹)ODividend Growth (Dₜ = D₀(1+g)ᵗ)Discounted Present Value (PV = Dₜ / (1+r)ᵗ)P₅Year 5₹146.93
Gordon Growth Model: Dividends grow at **8%**, discounted at **10%** (r = 10%, g = 8%).

Step-by-Step Solution

  1. Identify inputs:

    • (last year’s dividend)
    • (growth rate)
    • (required return)
  2. Calculate (next year’s dividend):

  3. Apply Gordon Growth Model:

Interpretation: The stock is fairly valued at Rs 176. If the market price is higher (e.g., Rs 200), it may be overvalued.


5. Real-World Applications in Nepal

Example 1: NEPSE Stocks (NMB Bank)

  • Idea Used: Constant-Growth DDM
  • How? NMB Bank’s dividends grew at ~8% annually. An investor using and would calculate: If the stock trades at Rs 350, it’s undervalued.

Example 2: eSewa’s Dividend Policy

  • Idea Used: Zero-Growth DDM (if dividends are stable)
  • How? eSewa’s parent company (F1Soft) declares fixed dividends to shareholders. If and , the intrinsic value is: This justifies why eSewa’s shares (if traded) would reflect this valuation.

Example 3: Pathao’s Equity Financing

  • Idea Used: Multi-Stage DDM
  • How? Pathao raised funds by promising high growth initially () but stabilizing later (). Investors discounted:
    • Stage 1 (Years 1–5): High dividends (if any) at 20% growth.
    • Stage 2 (Year 6+): Terminal value calculated using constant growth.

6. Limitations of DDM

While powerful, DDM has critical flaws:

  1. Ignores Non-Dividend Cash Flows: Buybacks, stock splits, or capital gains are excluded.
  2. Sensitive to Inputs: Small errors in or drastically change .
  3. Assumes Perpetuity: Unrealistic for firms with finite lifespans (e.g., startups).
  4. No Growth Firms: Fails for companies that never pay dividends (e.g., Amazon in its early years).

Mermaid Diagram: DDM’s Blind Spots

mindmap
  root((DDM Limitations))
    Ignores Buybacks
    Sensitive to r and g
    Assumes Perpetuity
    Fails for No-Dividend Firms

7. Numerical Problem: Zero-Growth DDM

Question: Kathmandu Retail Shop pays a fixed annual dividend of Rs 200. If investors require a 12% return, what is the stock’s intrinsic value?

Solution: Answer: The stock should trade at Rs 1,667.


8. Exam Tip: How to Score Full Marks

  1. Memorize the Three DDM Formulas:

    • Zero-growth:
    • Constant-growth:
    • Multi-stage: Break into stages + terminal value.
  2. Show All Steps:

    • Always write explicitly.
    • Label as "required return" and as "growth rate."
  3. Watch for Traps:

    • Growth rate () must be < : If , the denominator becomes zero or negative → model breaks.
    • Units matter: Ensure dividends and returns are in the same currency/time period (e.g., annual vs. monthly).
  4. Real-World Linking:

    • In essay questions, connect DDM to NEPSE stocks, dividend policies of Nepali banks, or startup valuations (e.g., Pathao).
  5. Practice Past Papers:

    • Questions often mix DDM with WACC (Unit 7) or cost of equity (Unit 4). Example:

      "If a firm’s cost of equity is 14% and dividends grow at 8%, calculate its stock price given ." Solution: .


9. Common Mistakes to Avoid

Mistake Why It’s Wrong How to Fix
Using instead of Dividends grow after the current period. Always calculate .
Ignoring rule Leads to division by zero or negative prices. Check before applying the formula.
Mixing nominal/growth rates Inflation can distort real growth. Use real rates if comparing across time.
Forgetting terminal value in multi-stage Underestimates long-term worth. Always include for Stage 2.

10. Visual Summary: The Accounting Cycle of DDM

Based on the TU BBA syllabus for Basic Finance (FIN211), unit 5.

Discussion

Loading…