Business Environment & Globalization: Forces, Ethics, and Nepal’s Challenges

TAKEAWAYS:

• The business environment is divided into internal (company-controlled) and external (uncontrollable) forces, with the external environment further split into macro (PESTEL) and micro (customers, suppliers, competitors).
• Globalization drives opportunities (market expansion, innovation) but also risks (cultural clashes, job displacement), requiring firms to adapt strategies like localization (e.g., Daraz’s Nepali-language app) or outsourcing (e.g., Ncell’s call-center partnerships).
• Ethical decision-making follows criteria like utilitarianism (greatest good), rights-based ethics (fairness), and justice—critical for Nepal’s context (e.g., NTC’s corruption scandals vs. Himalayan Java’s fair-trade practices).
• Nepal’s business challenges include infrastructure gaps (e.g., erratic electricity for eSewa), political instability (e.g., Daraz’s delayed tax reforms), and cultural resistance (e.g., Pathao’s gender bias in driver hiring).
• Environmental scanning (monitoring trends via SWOT, PESTEL, or Porter’s Five Forces) is a proactive tool—e.g., NEPSE tracking global oil prices to predict stock volatility.
• Sustainability is no longer optional: Companies like Chaudhary Group (solar-powered factories) or Nabil Bank (green loans) integrate ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance) into core strategies to future-proof operations.

---

1. The Business Environment: A Dynamic Ecosystem

The business environment is the external context in which a company operates, influencing its success or failure. It is divided into two broad categories:

A. Internal Environment (Controllable)

Factors within the organization that management can influence:

• Company culture (e.g., Nabil Bank’s "customer-first" ethos).
• Resources (financial, human, technological).
• Structures (hierarchy, departments).
• Leadership style (e.g., Daraz’s top-down vs. Pathao’s flat structure).

B. External Environment (Uncontrollable)

Divided into micro (immediate stakeholders) and macro (broad societal forces).

Why it matters:

• Micro forces directly impact daily operations. Example: When NTC raised internet prices in 2023, Pathao had to adjust surge pricing algorithms to avoid driver protests.
• Macro forces shape long-term strategy. Example: Nepal’s 2079 BS Electricity Act forced eSewa to invest in backup generators for its payment gateways.

---

2. The Macro Environment: PESTEL Analysis

The PESTEL framework helps businesses scan macro-environmental trends. Let’s break it down with Nepal-specific examples:

Worked Example: NTC’s Internet Tariff Hike (2023)

1. Political: Government aimed to reduce subsidy burdens.
2. Economic: Higher costs for digital businesses (e.g., Khalti’s transaction fees rose).
3. Social: Students protested (online classes disrupted).
4. Technological: Pathao drivers demanded compensation for lower earnings.
5. Environmental: No direct link, but data centers (e.g., Ncell’s) faced higher energy costs.
6. Legal: Competition Commission had to review anti-monopoly concerns.

Outcome: NTC introduced off-peak pricing to mitigate backlash.

---

3. Globalization: Opportunities and Threats

Globalization refers to the interconnectedness of economies, cultures, and technologies worldwide. It affects businesses in Nepal through:

A. Drivers of Globalization

1. Technology: E-commerce (Daraz, Amazon), social media (Facebook for ads), cloud computing (eSewa’s servers in Singapore).
2. Trade Agreements: SAARC, BIMSTEC, FTA with China/India.
3. Cultural Exchange: Nepali diaspora spending ($5B remittances/year).
4. Investment Flows: Chinese BRI projects (e.g., Budhi Gandaki hydropower).

B. Effects of Globalization on Nepal’s Business

Case Study: Daraz in Nepal

• Opportunity: Leveraged Alibaba’s global supply chain to offer 1M+ products.
• Challenge: Localization required:
  • Nepali language support.
  • Cash-on-delivery (90% of orders).
  • Logistics partnerships with Nepal Post (due to poor road infrastructure).
• Result: Daraz became Nepal’s #1 e-commerce platform (60% market share).

---

4. Business Ethics in Nepal: Balancing Profit and Principle

Definition: Business ethics refers to principles and standards that guide decision-making to balance profit, legality, and morality.

Criteria for Ethical Decision-Making

1. Utilitarian Approach: "Greatest good for the greatest number."
   • Example: Nabil Bank’s microfinance loans to rural women (empowers 500K+ families).
2. Rights-Based Approach: Respecting stakeholders’ rights.
   • Example: Himalayan Java’s fair-trade certification (farmers earn 30% more).
3. Justice-Based Approach: Fair distribution of benefits/burdens.
   • Example: NTC’s subsidized internet for schools (but criticized for corruption).
4. Virtue Ethics: Upholding moral character.
   • Example: Chaudhary Group’s "No Bribery" policy (despite political pressures).

Real-World Dilemma: eSewa’s Data Privacy

• Issue: eSewa shares user transaction data with banks (for fraud detection) but not with the government (despite NPRB requests).
• Ethical Conflict:
  • Utilitarian: Sharing data could reduce fraud (benefiting all users).
  • Rights-Based: Users have a right to privacy (GDPR-like concerns).
• Solution: eSewa implemented anonymized data sharing and user consent pop-ups.

---

5. Nepal’s Business Challenges: A SWOT Lens

Despite globalization’s benefits, Nepal faces unique hurdles:

Key Problems with Real Examples:

1. Infrastructure Gaps:
   • Example: Pathao’s delivery delays in Bhaktapur due to poor roads.
   • Impact: 40% of orders are canceled in hilly regions.
2. Political Instability:
   • Example: Daraz’s warehouse seizures in 2021 over tax disputes.
   • Impact: 2-week shutdown during peak Diwali sales.
3. Cultural Resistance:
   • Example: Khalti’s failure in rural areas where cash is king.
   • Impact: Only 30% of Nepalis use digital payments (vs. 80% in India).
4. Corruption:
   • Example: NTC’s tender process for 5G spectrum (alleged favoritism to Ncell).
   • Impact: Delays in broadband expansion.

Solution Strategies:

• Public-Private Partnerships (PPP): NTC + Ncell for fiber-optic cables.
• Digital Literacy Programs: Nepal Rastra Bank’s "Cashless Nepal" campaign.
• Localized Products: Daraz’s "Made in Nepal" section (e.g., Thakali momos).

---

6. Environmental Scanning: Proactive Intelligence

Definition: The process of monitoring trends in the external environment to anticipate changes and adjust strategies.

Tools for Environmental Scanning

Worked Example: NEPSE’s Environmental Scan (2023)

1. Political: New SEBON regulations → Stricter IPO approvals.
2. Economic: Rupee depreciation → Higher import costs for listed firms.
3. Technological: Crypto bans → Investors shift to stocks.
4. Action Taken:
   • NEPSE introduced "Sustainability Index" for green stocks.
   • Investor education campaigns on digital trading (via eSewa integration).

---

7. Sustainability and ESG: The Future of Business

ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance) is now a non-negotiable factor for investors and customers.

ESG in Nepal: Case Studies

Why ESG Matters for Nepal:

• Investor Attraction: NEPSE’s ESG-listed firms see 15% higher valuation.
• Regulatory Compliance: NPRB’s 2023 circular mandates ESG disclosures for banks.
• Consumer Demand: 60% of Kathmandu youth prefer sustainable brands (per Nepal Sustainability Survey 2023).

---

8. Globalization vs. Localization: Finding the Balance

Companies must adapt global strategies to local contexts. Examples:

Worked Example: Toyota’s Entry into Nepal

1. Global Strategy: Hybrid cars (environmentally friendly).
2. Local Adaptation:
   • Price: Corolla Altis priced at NPR 5.5M (vs. NPR 3M in India).
   • Fuel: Dual-fuel models (petrol + CNG) for Nepal’s high oil prices.
   • Warranty: Extended to 5 years (vs. 3 years globally) due to rough roads.
3. Result: #1 car brand in Nepal (40% market share).

---

## In the Real World

1. eSewa’s Ethical Dilemma:

   • Idea Used: Rights-Based Ethics (user privacy vs. fraud detection).
   • How It Works: eSewa anonymizes transaction data for banks but never shares raw data with the government, balancing security and privacy.

2. Daraz’s Localization Strategy:

   • Idea Used: Glocalization (global platform + local needs).
   • How It Works:
     • Payment: 90% of orders are Cash-on-Delivery (vs. 10% globally).
     • Inventory: Stocks Nepali brands (e.g., Thakali spices, Newari handicrafts).
     • Logistics: Partners with Nepal Post for rural deliveries (vs. FedEx globally).

3. Nabil Bank’s Microfinance:

   • Idea Used: Utilitarian Ethics (empowering women = economic growth).
   • How It Works:
     • Target: Rural women (who lack collateral for loans).
     • Impact: 500,000+ women now run small businesses (e.g., tailoring, dairy).
     • Outcome: NPR 20B in loans disbursed since 2010, with 95% repayment rate.

---

## Exam Tip: How to Score Full Marks

1. Define Clearly:

   • Always start with precise definitions (e.g., "Business ethics refers to the application of moral principles in business decisions...").
   • Example Answer Start:

     "The business environment consists of two primary components: the internal environment (controllable factors like company culture and resources) and the external environment (uncontrollable factors such as PESTEL forces)."

2. Use Nepal Examples:

   • Examiners love local cases. Always tie theory to Nepal’s context (e.g., NTC, Daraz, Nabil Bank).
   • Avoid: Generic examples like "Coca-Cola in India."

3. Diagrams = Easy Marks:

   • Draw PESTEL tables, SWOT mindmaps, or Porter’s Five Forces diagrams.
   • Example: For "Discuss the major problems of business in Nepal", use a SWOT diagram with 3 strengths, 2 weaknesses, 2 opportunities, 2 threats.

4. Link to Globalization:

   • For questions on globalization, always discuss:
     • Opportunities (e.g., Daraz’s FDI).
     • Threats (e.g., job displacement in textiles).
     • Adaptation strategies (e.g., localization).

5. Ethics Questions:

   • Use the 4 criteria (utilitarian, rights-based, justice, virtue) to analyze dilemmas.
   • Example: For "Define business ethics and criteria", write:

     "The utilitarian approach would support eSewa’s data-sharing with banks to reduce fraud, benefiting all users. However, the rights-based approach argues that users have a privacy right, making this unethical without consent."

6. Problem-Solving Format:

   • For "Strategic approach vs. problem-solving", structure your answer as:
     1. Define both (strategic = long-term; problem-solving = short-term).
     2. Example: "Nabil Bank uses a strategic approach (ESG integration) to future-proof against climate risks, while problem-solving (offering green loans) addresses immediate customer needs."
     3. Conclusion: "Both are essential: strategy sets direction, while problem-solving ensures survival."

7. Common Pitfalls to Avoid:

   • ❌ Vague answers: "Globalization is good" → Wrong. Say "Globalization offers market access (e.g., Daraz) but risks cultural erosion (e.g., momo shops closing)."
   • ❌ Ignoring Nepal: Always localize global concepts.
   • ❌ Overcomplicating: Stick to 3-4 key points per question.

---

## Quick Revision Checklist

Before the exam, ask yourself: ✅ Can I draw a PESTEL table for Nepal’s business environment? ✅ Can I explain ESG with a Nepal company example (e.g., Chaudhary Group)? ✅ Can I compare globalization’s pros/cons using Daraz vs. Ncell? ✅ Can I apply the 4 ethical criteria to a real dilemma (e.g., eSewa’s data privacy)? ✅ Can I list 2 major problems of Nepal’s business environment with solutions?